DIY Body Butter

Connie Casey • October 5, 2026

I am at a place where I am taking baby steps in an attempt to ditch some of the chemicals we slather on ourselves every day. I found this recipe for body butter to replace store-bought lotion that seemed easy enough! I was SO pleased with the outcome that I have continued to use it for a few years now. 


My only tip: if you feel it is too oily for your taste, add a tablespoon of arrowroot powder when whipping! Give it a try! This would be a fun quick project to do and split with girlfriends since there will be lots of leftover ingredients, especially if you have to purchase new packages of each. 

Ingredients

½ cup shea butter

¼ cup coconut oil

2 tablespoons sweet almond oil (or your preferred oil)

About 30 drops of essential oil (I used Wild Orange, which is not sun-friendly, so I only use it at night)


Be sure you know the do’s and don’ts of your oil of choice. 

Directions

Add water to the bottom of your double boiler, filling it 3/4 full. Set it on the stove and turn your burner to medium-high.


While the water is warming up, measure out ½ cup shea butter and ¼ cup coconut oil. Place these two ingredients in the top portion of your double boiler and set in on the water-filled base.


Adjust heat to medium-low so it doesn't boil, so your shea butter and coconut oil will slowly melt into a golden puddle.


After it has melted, pour the colorful liquid into a mixing bowl. Set it in a cool place and wait for things to firm up. I put mine in the refrigerator to speed this process up.


Once the shea butter and coconut oil have returned to a solid state, it's time to fluff the ingredients. I used a hand mixer with the wire whisk attachments.


Whip the solids for 15 seconds or so, until they resemble the consistency of sour cream. Measure out and slowly add 2 tablespoons of liquid oil to the creamy butter. Whip for another 15 seconds.

Portrait of Connie Casey with text listing her roles: wife, mom, homesteader, artist, farm girl, boarding biz owner

Other Articles

Assorted handmade ceramic cups and bowls on a blue surface, including pink and cream pieces with polka dots.
By Miranda Johnson • October 22, 2026
We talk a lot about learning skills. And that matters. But not every step has to be serious. Sometimes learning looks like trying something new with people you enjoy being around.
Miranda Johnson and Cammeron LaVecchia flanking Joel Salatin
By Miranda Johnson • September 27, 2026
Whether you live on a large farm, a few acres, a suburban lot, or in the middle of town, there's a place for you at this Gathering.
Smiling couple outdoors by the Polyface Farm wooden sign in a wooded area
By Nancy Anderson • August 21, 2026
Some places you read about for years, study from afar, and hope that someday you’ll have the opportunity to experience it. Polyface Farm is one of those places.
Show More